Guess the Vote · house mode
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee of the whole House
Commons vote. A recorded vote of the House of Commons. The exact wording voted on is at the source link.
Formally: Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee of the whole House: Clause 18 stand part · division 213, 19 Apr 2023
The record says otherwise
The House said YES - it went through.
AYE 0
NO 0
How the parties broke
288-0
0-163
0-41
5-8
0-3
The twist: 5 MPs voted against most of their own party.
Matt Hancock (Independent, aye) · Andrew Bridgen (Independent, aye) · Julian Knight (Independent, aye) · David Warburton (Independent, aye) · Rob Roberts (Independent, aye) - counted against each party's own majority (where ≥5 voted and ≥60% went one way).
See the receipt - the official division, hash-stamped